As i suggested before use an IDE that tabs for you.
<?php
if (in_array($_POST['crime'], array(1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6))) {
if (rand(0, 100) <= $crime_information[($_POST['crime'] - 1)]) {
$suc = "yes";
echo str_replace('{money}', $payout, $crime_success_text[$_POST['crime']]);
} else if (rand(1, 3) == 1) {
$jail = "yes";
echo "You failed to commit the crime and the cops caught you.";
} else {
echo "You failed to commit the crime.";
}
}
?>
^ done by netbeans for me.
On a positive note, well done. Looking very nice considering the file difference there. :)