Jump to content
MakeWebGames

Recommended Posts

Posted

Well, registration is as ugly as it can (every time you do something not ok it will cleanup all the fields and you are ready to start again), home site doesn't say anything about the game... and the game itself seems yet another McCode game without particular interest. Sorry but for me this isn't exactly something exciting.

Anyhow, for those which want to try it:

Username: gamedemo

Password: gamedemo

Posted

Dont worry I understand you fully but I have no clue when it comes to the look of the site thats why I have chosen to keep it simple. Hope you understand what I mean.

If theres anyone that can do a login and a register I would be intererested ive actually been looking for someone to do one for years now.

Posted

You asked for feedback, and I gave it. If you don't want any feedback (specially negative one), then don't ask for feedback ;)

That said, the home page doesn't contain anything about the story, you don't know what the game will be, you enter, and there again nothing, just things to click randomly until you get how it works. Sorry, even if this is a standard McCode way to do it's not a good way. You should enter a game and have at least an introduction page, some sort of tutorial to tell you what to do etc...

On the "lack of uniqueness", sorry again, but what does your game offers that the others don't? I don't see it... Even the titles of the different "menu" are standard in my opinion...

Posted

Maybe so but what the things are called dont mean much to me is about what is within the pages.

Because I know ive changed just about every page and added so many features to the game (just look at announcements) thats why i gave the reply that I gave.

You are right about the story thing I had all of that up at one point.

But new players said it was a bit heavy and it put them off seeing so many links when they logged in for the first time so I took it out.

The storyline can be found in city central :)

The actualy login page is as simpe as it is because i dont want people to register who isnt interested in playing the game frankly.

But im ready/willing to pay someone to make a registration and login page for me and i have been looking for someone for years.

Dont you know anyone ?

Posted

How can one know if we are interested or not to register and play if we don't even know what your game contains? And this is exactly one of the major issue with most McCode game => home pages are... empty.

Posted

Hello,

I would personally have to agree 100% with what A_B is saying. The site has no uniqueness to it, even the template and login look like it's shoved together.

For advice, I would go for a new template (not saying you have to choose me) and with in that new template make each look differently then what it is. Come up with something unique then just the regular MCCodes Menu. I am sure since you are asking you are looking for advice and are trying to find ways to improve to gain more members. As right now you have like 5 members on in 15 minutes and 11 in the last hour.

I would myself remove the ads. They aren't pretty on a game site and put majority of gamers off and do not play. Having your members have to pay to remove the ads is just wrong in my own honest opinion. If you are trying to make the game a real success, get a template and work on reformatting (don't have to recode the script to do something else) the pages to look differently.

Posted

I get what you guys are aaying but you guys failed to notice that the game has been going for over 1000 days

It is no longer at a point where I can just change the name of links in the main menu just because i feel like it. I hope you understand my point.

As I said earlier ive been looking for someone to do me up a new login and registration for years now as I myself I am hopeless with those things.

So I guess you may be right by saying it was shoved together.

The only point I am trying to make is. People still play my game so obviously there is some uniqueness to the game or it would have died and failed long before 1000days.

Not saying is a GREAT game but is not as bad as you guys seem to make it sound like.

And due to the lack of postiveness in the ealier posts is why I know you guys have no actually played the game and just taken a quick glance.

Well I guess you can only really get a quick glance and tell me what you think but im #justsaying

Posted

hi there

 

Hey guys come check out my game www.seriouswars.net

Is a bit old but it would be great to see what you guys think about my game/project :D

 

Hello there mate i know your game has been on here over 2 years now so i think its time people stop taking the "piss" and acttualy show enthusiasm in this game so im offering to help you out a little bit providing you want it this could become bigger than what it is so all im asking for is you to say yes first 6months is free if you like my progress i will be chargin £2 a month and that is all p.s kyle contact 8) me back Asap as i could be helping others

Posted

Sure, I didn't really played but just tested you basically asked ("Is a bit old but it would be great to see what you guys think about my game/project"). And if at start you don't make some efforts to keep people around you will basically loose a lot of players which may be interested. Also if you are not ready to accept negative feedback, then don't ask for reviews ;) Yet I don't remember I said it's all junk and you should stop working on it. I just gave you some of my thought which are mine and not holy words. You don't think I'm right? fine simply don't follow my feedback. Same goes for any other feedback you got.

You must remember you are on a board which as a strong majority of McCode developers (I'm not one), so what we see here is the always too similar McCode game. Sure some people out there don't know it and may enjoy it, yet you should understand that you must make quiet some effort to surprise us.

Posted

Hi there

Okay so i'm going to be brutally honest and give you my personal opinion seems as you asked for it.

Login page, where to start, the images at the top are all used for other games (not online text based games either) and they are all copyrighted to the owners, so before anything you are in breach of copyright, consider getting some mascots made up, if ever you was to make it big and them images get reported to the correct authorities your in for a large fine.

Next your use of tables on the login page for me are not aesthetically pleasing and as such indicates to me that the interior of the game is going to be similar.

Register page: For me this is even worse, same copyight infringed images and same pretty awful table design. What i cant decide if it makes matters worse is the fact your table isn't even aligned centrally correctly.

Baring in mind these two pages are the first your users will see its not a good look. Oh and NO CAPTCHA on your registration page, it is utterly essential you get one.

 

Ingame. I took one look and straight away i knew i was to never return. All that black is not a good look, the advert across the top is a big no for me and just the jumble of absolutely everything turns me away.

 

Brutally honest, but you wont improve if everyone pussy foots about saying its okay but needs work.

Posted

When I read all this bullshit it just tells me to quit trying -_-

I still see nothing positive come out of these forums

Im just happy my players appreciate the work that I have put in and dont share your negativity

And now im getting emails that my game is not valid why would I need I need it be valid if used lite as my start up codes ?

Posted
Hey guys come check out my game http://www.seriouswars.net

Is a bit old but it would be great to see what you guys think about my game/project :D

As we can clearly see you are asking people to sum up your overall project, nothing about certain bits, ect.

 

As for the bad feedback, They are just trying too help, it's no point saying your site is amazing if in there hearts there thinking it's awful.

 

 

Posted

As a followup to something you said earlier, if this game is really based off MCCodes Lite then you should have no licensing issues whatsoever and can simply ignore the people saying it's unlegit.

Posted

Dementor you are taking the criticism to strongly...

As common with many things, people will point out the bad before they mention the good...

Your game has active players and as you said have been around for a while, so you must be doing something right :)

Best of luck to you and the future of your game :)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...