OK, I'm not taking side. But, Dave's probably spent alot of time on PS to get as good as he is(Not the mascots). So all I can say, Dave's a pro because he earn't it, and worked hard. You messaged me on MSN and said, something you have't been doing it for long, so take advice.
The layout itself, is kind of a good idea, but the graphics can be improved on(The font & Positions). Never ever start of paid, and I mean, A mistake....
But keep learning, and you end up were Dave is. Or even progress and surpass him, you never know. :)